Want to hear the AI receptionist? Call the demo line: (202) 980-4998

Angi vs Thumbtack for Contractors: How Leads and Fees Work

Contractor typing on a laptop at a workbench surrounded by tools

Angi and Thumbtack both sell you homeowners looking for help, and both charge per lead rather than per click. Ask ten contractors about them and you’ll hear that one “is a waste of money” and the other “pays for my truck”, often from two people in the same trade and town. The difference usually comes down to how each platform charges, how many other pros you’re up against, and how fast you respond.

Here’s how Angi and Thumbtack work for pros, from each company’s own help center on 22 October 2026, plus how to decide whether either is worth testing. We make Ansdale, an AI receptionist for contractors. We don’t sell leads, so we’ve no stake in which one you choose.

How do Angi and Thumbtack charge pros?

AngiThumbtack
When you payWhen you and the homeowner both show interest in connectingAutomatically for leads that match your job preferences; for Opportunities, only if the customer replies
Who sets the priceAngi; fees change with the task, location and demandYou choose a price level with a slider; Thumbtack aims to match it to the job’s value
How many pros per requestNo more than fiveUp to five in the first four hours of a search
Refunds or creditsCredits for invalid contact info, wrong location, wrong service or duplicates, with conditionsAutomatic refund if the customer doesn’t reply to any pro within 72 hours

Neither publishes a standard lead price, because it depends on your trade, your market and the job. You’ll see Thumbtack’s price in your account before you commit to it, and Angi’s in your lead details.

What’s the catch with Angi?

Read the credit rules closely. Angi’s help center says you’re charged for leads “whether or not you open or respond to them.” To qualify for a credit, the lead has to be less than 45 days old, you should have tried to call the homeowner within 24 hours, and you can’t be on an annual subscription. Credits expire after six months. Pros on an annual subscription are billed monthly for their automatic leads under a budget set in their contract; others are billed weekly.

It’s also worth knowing the history. In April 2023 the FTC approved a final order requiring HomeAdvisor, which is part of Angi, to pay up to $7.2 million after the agency said it made false, misleading or unsubstantiated claims to service providers about the quality and source of its leads. That doesn’t tell you how leads perform today, but it’s a reason to track your results yourself rather than rely on a sales rep’s numbers.

What’s the catch with Thumbtack?

Thumbtack gives you more control over price: you set your lead prices, and the help center says that’s “the exact amount you’ll pay for each lead.” Set them too low and you’ll rarely show up; too high and the spend climbs quickly. You also pay for matched leads automatically, so loose job preferences mean paying for jobs you don’t want. Keep the services, job sizes and travel distance tight.

The Fair Shot refund helps with ghosting, but only when the customer replies to nobody. If they reply to someone else and hire them, you’ve paid for the lead.

Which one is better for contractors?

  • Thumbtack tends to suit pros who want control: you set the price and pick Opportunities by hand. It’s a lower-commitment way to test lead buying.
  • Angi can bring volume in some trades and markets, but understand the billing and credit rules, and any contract, before you sign.
  • Neither is a good fit if you can’t respond within minutes, because with up to five pros on a request, the fast one usually wins.

The fair test is a fixed budget for 60 to 90 days, tracked as cost per booked job. Compare that against Google Local Services Ads, which also charge per lead but put you in front of people searching Google directly. Our guide to roofing leads has questions worth asking any lead seller.

How do you win more leads on either platform?

  • Respond first. Thumbtack’s own help center says the faster you reply, the better your chances of getting hired. Our speed to lead guide covers what the research found.
  • Call, don’t just message, when the platform gives you a number. A voice beats a template.
  • Build your profile like a website. Real photos, clear prices where you can, and reviews. Our guide to getting more Google reviews covers a routine that works on any platform.
  • Answer the callback. When a lead rings you back and it goes to voicemail, you’ve paid for the lead and handed the job to someone else.

Ansdale, which is ours, is an AI receptionist that answers your existing number 24/7, books jobs into its calendar with two-way Google Calendar sync and routes urgent calls to you, from $49 a month for 100 AI minutes. When a lead calls back while you’re on a ladder, it still gets answered. For missed calls you do get, see missed call text back for contractors.

Questions people ask

Is Angi or Thumbtack better for contractors?

Thumbtack gives you more control because you set your lead prices and can choose Opportunities. Angi can bring volume in some markets but has stricter credit rules. Test either with a fixed budget and track cost per booked job.

How much do Angi and Thumbtack leads cost?

Neither publishes standard prices. Angi’s fees change with the task, location and demand. On Thumbtack you set your lead price level, and the cost reflects the job’s value and competition.

How many pros get the same lead?

Angi says it matches each request with no more than five pros. Thumbtack limits customers to contacting five pros in the first four hours of a search.

Can you get refunds for bad leads?

Angi gives credits for invalid contact info, wrong location, wrong service or duplicates if conditions are met. Thumbtack refunds automatically if the customer replies to no pro within 72 hours.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Start freeSee pricing
WhatsApp us(202) 960-2022 · messages